Summer Hours — Open 10am to 4:30pm — Closed Wednesday and Sunday

Reclaimed Consignment

you've never seen consignment done like this before

Are you buying or selling a furnished home? Are you downsizing, relocating, or redecorating and find you have items that you no longer need or use? Reclaimed is the perfect place to showcase your goods for others to purchase and enjoy. We will price, stage, advertise and market your items in order to ensure you a quick and profitable sale. Consigning with Reclaimed is easy to do. Here’s how it works…

60 Days

When you consign items with us our contract term is for 60 days. Our aim is to price items fairly and correctly for both consignor and customer. By careful pricing most items sell with in the first few weeks!

50/50 Split

Our Split is an even 50/50 with half of the final sale going to the consignor and half going to Reclaimed. We are partners in the sale. Any unsold items are returned to the consignor at the end of the term.

Whole Home & Large Consignments

Are you buying or selling a furnished home and have rooms of furniture and other items for consignment? Sizable consignments are familiar territory for us. We’ll make it easy by coming to you and coordinate all the details of a large scale consignment! Call us and we’ll schedule an in home visit to come out and view your items. We can also assist, if needed, for pick up and delivery to our store.

How to Consign

in three easy steps

Schedule Appointment
The first step in consigning with us is setting up an appointment time where we can meet and review your items. Appointments can be made by filling out the small form at the bottom of the page. You may also stop in or call us at to schedule an appointment at 920-854-3239.
Review Items & Pricing
On the day of your appointment, simply bring your items to the store. You’ll meet with one of our consignment team members. We’ll briefly discuss any pricing concerns you may have. We will price items based upon factors such as current market value and our experience of the resale market. Condition, brand, style, age and market demand of an item all are all considered when when pricing your goods. The final step is simply signing our consignment agreement. Your items will be inventoried into our P.O.S. System and will go out on our floor the same day. Simple! and you’ll receive a complete inventory list of the items you just dropped off.
Collect Your Money
After all of your items have sold or after 60 days (whichever comes first), your payout will be ready for you. Payouts come in the form of a check and can be picked up in store or mailed to you. Along with your payout you’ll receive an itemized list of sold/unsold items and your portion of the sale. Any unsold items must be picked up or we will be donate them.

see, pretty easy...

What We Accept

what's hot and what's not

We Do Accept

Home Decor
Home Goods
Bedroom Furniture
Living room Furniture
Dining room Furniture
Upholstered Furniture
Sm./Lg. Accent Furniture
Home Office Furniture
Holiday (In Season)
Outdoor Furniture
Vintage Or Antique Items

We Do Not Accept

Mattresses Alone
Commercial Office Furniture
Stained, Ripped or Worn Upholstered Furniture
Sm. Knick Knacks (in abundance)
Cribs/Baby Furniture
Exercise Equipment
Items in Need of Repair

this is not an exhaustive list

Schedule Consignment Appointment

To set up an appointment where we can discuss and view your items, please fill out the form below so we can get in touch with you. We look forward to meeting you and your items.

Things to Know Before You Go

Neat, Clean & Tidy

Items should be clean and ready to presented for resale. The better it looks – the better it sells.

Items Declined

During item review, we may not accept some of your items. Our goal is to take in items that we know our customers are looking for or we have a market for. While all items may not be a fit there is a market for everything. It’s just finding the right place.

Heavy Lifting

Its best to bring additional help for heavier items as we are not always available to help you lift.

Seasonal Items
We gladly accept seasonal items within the current season. (Americana in June/July or a fall wreath in September/October etc.)

Need Transportation of Large Pieces?

If you are unable to deliver large pieces to our store let us know – we have pick up and delivery services available!

Reclaimed Reviews

a vote of confidence from our consignors

“Reclaimed is an upscale consignment shop where you can sell your high end furniture and home accessories. Tena and Jeff are wonderful people to work with! An added plus is their sign making area where you can create a sign for your home. Many designs to choose from! A fun activity…”

– Heidi L.

“I couldn’t be more satisfied with Reclaimed; they are classy, detail oriented, know what will sell, and make delightful “room settings” with the items that they are selling. They also keep good records of what has sold and what still remains!”

– Pat W.

“Having consigned several items at Reclaimed last summer, it is truly a first class, quality oriented resale shop. Tena (the owner) is excellent to work with…very professional, great communicator, business efficient and a really nice person.”

– Heidi K.

“I recently had the pleasure of interacting with the owners of Reclaimed. After my initial discussion with Tena regarding the process, I can say it all went very smoothly. My items, which I might add had sentimental value, were handled respectfully and carefully. Everything sold within a short period of time. I would not hesitate to work with them again in the future. In addition, a friend of mine had a wood plaque made for her daughters engagement. It was nothing short of beautiful. My thanks to Tena and her family. A great addition to our neighborhood.”

– Gayle G.

“We are extremely pleased with our experience at Reclaimed. The process was easy but the record keeping was professional and accurate. We felt that Tena was actually excited about selling our furniture and accessories and we had great results. We highly recommend Reclaimed consignment sales.”

– Doug and Penny S.

“First class consignment!! Very upscale merchandise. The prices are fair and the owners are a delight to work with whether you are consigning or buying!”

– Eileen and Floyd T.

“My consignment experience at Reclaimed has been very good.  The space is beautiful and it attracts locals as well as tourists.  Tena is fun, organized and very conscientious.  Go for it!”

– Ann H.

“You were so thoughtful, very helpful & I was happy with all the final results. You did an excellent job & I thank you again. Stay cozy in Door County!”

– Sally G.